The Nights Before Christmas Movie Review

What happens when a movie is so lovely and profound it inspires you to revive your entertainment-writing journey? Well, you pick up your pen again and find yourself scribbling away, trying to convey how powerful movies can be. That’s what happened with the Hallmark original Christmas movie, The Nights Before Christmas. Indeed, many other original Hallmark films that I watched for the first time this year sparked similar feelings, but there’s something about Christmas films that remains unmatched. Spoilers ahead…

Image Credit: Hallmark Crown Media and Tyler Hynes.

The Nights Before Christmas stars beloved Hallmark staple Tyler Hynes, the man whose effortless charm has won the hearts of countless fans, and the lovely and warm Laci J. Mailey, whom viewers know from Chesapeake Shores (2016-2022) and An Alpine Holiday (2025). Directed by Lucie Guest and written by Russell Hainline, the movie presents a premise we’ve seen many times in films like Groundhog Day (1993) and other holiday movies, including an all-time favorite of mine, 12 Dates of Christmas (2011). Marty (Hynes) finds himself stuck in a time loop on Christmas Eve, and must find a way to break free from repeating the day over and over again.

With a premise we’ve seen so often, the challenge becomes clear: how do we make the concept fresh, engaging, and meaningful? The Nights Before Christmas not only succeeds, but manages to be one of the finest films Hallmark has ever produced, period.

Instead of feeling annoyed or distraught by his plight, Marty enjoys his predicament, using the opportunity to see and do countless things. From watching every film and learning new languages and musical instruments, to meeting and speaking with countless people around New York City, Marty loves every moment of it. That is, until he meets Chloe (Mailey), a sweet journalist who finally makes him want to escape the never-ending monotony of no tomorrow.

Image Credit: Hallmark Crown Media.

Whereas the film’s beginning with Marty’s pure joy gives the film its humor and originality, the moment he meets Chloe, and their time spent together, gives the film its heart and profundity. Marty’s character is charming and funny, and combined with those tender and vulnerable moments, Hynes truly shines. It’s not just about disarming good looks and seemingly effortless charisma- which, of course, Hynes has in spades. It’s the ability to remain likable in moments where the character could come across as less than altruistic, such as when he uses everything Chloe tells him about what she looks for in a man to his advantage. Moreover, he exudes great depth and warmth, particularly towards the film’s conclusion. When Marty realizes how much he loves Chloe, and how to free himself from the loop, Hynes solidifies an overall exceptional performance and gives the film its true heart.

Laci J. Mailey is also wonderful as Chloe, a character I saw a lot of myself in. In a time when journalists and writers are struggling against the emergence of AI and shortened attention spans, her struggles hit close to home. When she cries over the loss of her ornaments and her parents being unable to be with her on Christmas Day, I really felt that because it’s these traditions that bring us comfort in tough times. As someone who loves Christmas, decorating, and is extremely close to her parents, I found these attributes very relatable. Likewise, her openness and sweetness radiate from her, creating such a warm and natural chemistry between her and Hynes. It was refreshing to see a character that’s open and free with her affection and belief in him but never naive or meek.

The film’s strength comes from these performances, the engaging script from Hainline, and lovely direction by Guest. Not for nothing, but The Nights Before Christmas is one of the prettiest and most visually dynamic Hallmark films I’ve ever seen. It looks better than many Hollywood films that have much larger budgets.

Image Credit: Hallmark Crown Media.

Lastly, I’d be remiss not to mention the film’s usage and parallels to the Frank Capra Christmas masterpiece, It’s a Wonderful Life. Many films have referenced the James Stewart and Donna Reed classic, so it’d be easy for its inclusion to come across as trite or prosaic. On the contrary, I found the parallels well-earned, helping drive home the movie’s sincerity and themes. Like George Bailey (Stewart) offers to lasso the moon for Mary (Reed), Marty wants to make the seemingly impossible happen and bring Chloe’s parents to her so they can celebrate Christmas together. And those numerous efforts are some of the funniest and most heartwarming of all.

Moreover, as George Bailey realizes that life is worth living, Marty’s realizes that a life with no tomorrow means nothing with no one to share it- and that proves deeply moving. Love wakes him up, but the act of true love, which makes him think beyond his own happiness, is what finally frees him. That is what makes the ending so satisfying and profound. Instead of ending in the traditional Hallmark way with a kiss (as the two shared a sweet kiss earlier in the film), the movie ends with Marty and Chloe walking down the street together. While he retains his memories of all they shared, all she sees is the kind man who generously reunited her parents with her. But that’s enough. They are walking towards hope, and in this fast-paced and often cynical day and age, a film that’s led by hope is exactly what we need.

Leave a Reply